When it comes to HR challenges, many small-to-medium business owners (SMBs) don’t know what they don’t know—until they’re suddenly facing unchartered territory like keeping up with employment laws or handling tax regulations.
There are several ways to manage HR, from doing it in-house to outsourcing specific tasks or the entire function. But as a business grows, so do the challenges, like managing the unique payroll needs of a larger team. Every approach to HR has its pros and cons, so the real question is: which one makes the most sense for your business?
DIY, Full-Time, Consultant, or Fractional HR?
Each option comes with trade-offs. While DIY might seem like a budget-friendly choice upfront, it can end up costing you more in the long run because of costly mistakes and increased risk; and hiring a full-time HR manager simply may not be in the budget yet. A consultant is great for expert advice, particularly ideal for one-time projects such as performing a compliance review, but their high rates will add up fast and may not be sustainable. Engaging a fractional HR partner is a smart middle-ground solution that’ll give you the expertise you need and will bridge the gap until you’re ready to bring someone on board full-time.
What Makes Fractional HR a Good Option for Growing Businesses?
The advantages of engaging the right fractional expert extend well beyond the sheer talent they bring to your company. The power dynamic is different, allowing for a more forthright discussion of issues, and there is an element of advising and mentoring that can be hugely beneficial to business owners. Also, because of the nature of their work, they bring a breadth of experience and exposure to different ways of doing things. This means they can help you tackle problems in fresh ways while also drawing on tried-and-true methods.
Instead of handling pressing human resource issues in a reactive way only when the need is urgent and significant—a fractional HR partner can transform HR into a proactive, strategic, comprehensive function that evolves with your business.
Here are just a few ways they can provide tailored support:
- Hiring & Onboarding: Find and attract the right talent with structured onboarding, and offer employee handbook suggestions.
- Compliance & Risk Management: Stay up to date with employment laws and avoid costly fines.
- Payroll & Benefits: Ensure proper classification, fair wages, and competitive benefits.
- Employee Retention: Improve culture and engagement to keep your best employees.
Scenario: Avoiding Costly Mistakes with Fractional HR
To illustrate how fractional HR can prevent common pitfalls for small businesses, let’s consider a scenario that many growing companies can relate to.
Janet’s bakery took off faster than she expected. At first, she managed hiring and payroll herself, but as she expanded to multiple locations, things got messy. She accidentally misclassified some of her new employees as independent contractors, triggering a potential tax penalty. She also missed key labor law differences between her two locations—just 30 minutes apart but in different states—putting her at risk of non-compliance.
Overwhelmed, Janet brought in a fractional HR partner. They quickly corrected the misclassifications, ensured she met legal requirements, and put structured hiring and onboarding processes in place. They also created an employee handbook to standardize policies across locations. Now, with the right systems in place, Janet no longer worries about compliance issues or last-minute hiring scrambles. She’s set up for steady, sustainable growth—without the risk of costly mistakes.
How to Choose the Right Fractional HR Partner for Your Business
Getting started with a fractional HR partner means figuring out where you’re struggling with HR and what kind of help you need within your budget. A good working relationship starts with open conversations about the job itself: What gaps are you trying to fill, and what kind of experience does the right person need to have?
The ideal fractional HR partner should have real-world experience working with small and mid-sized businesses. They need to be familiar with the specific labor laws in the states where you operate and have a strong track record of successfully helping businesses like yours navigate compliance, hiring, and employee management. They should also be comfortable with modern HR technology and best practices so they can recommend solutions that actually make your life easier.
Your HR partner should be easy to reach, responsive, and committed to adapting as your business evolves. By keeping the lines of communication open, setting clear expectations, and treating them like part of the team, you’ll build a working relationship that can handle the ups and downs of running a business—while keeping your HR in good hands.
Commonwealth Payroll & HR Can Handle It All for You
If juggling HR tasks is pulling you away from actually running your business, it’s time for a better solution. At CommPayHR, we take the burden off your plate—whether that means fully managing your payroll so you never have to think about tax filings and direct deposits or building a rock-solid employee handbook that keeps you compliant and sets clear expectations for your team. Our fractional HR services are designed to fit your business, giving you expert support without the cost of a full-time hire. Contact us today!
TOP